Narrow, Outdated, Scientifically Inaccurate: Unpacking Federal Directives Related to Gender
An Executive Order, issued on January 20, 2025, by President Donald Trump, primarily seeks to define and enforce a binary, biological understanding of sex (male and female), rejecting the concept of gender identity as separate from biological sex. The order takes aim at what it calls "gender ideology," which it criticizes for promoting fluid and subjective notions of gender identity that are divorced from biological reality.
Key Points of the Order:
Biological Essentialism: The order insists on recognizing only two sexes—male and female—based on immutable biological characteristics, which it argues must be the basis for all legal and policy decisions.
Defining "Sex" and "Gender": It distinguishes between "sex" (biological, unchangeable) and "gender" (which it sees as a subjective, ideological concept), claiming that gender identity is internally inconsistent and incompatible with legal frameworks that depend on biological sex.
Policy Enforcement: The order mandates that federal agencies cease promoting gender ideology, redefine women’s and men’s roles strictly in terms of biological sex, and ensure that spaces such as prisons and shelters remain segregated by biological sex.
Gender Identity and Legal Rights: It argues that policies allowing individuals to access single-sex spaces based on gender identity (such as in schools or shelters) harm women’s safety and legal rights.
Reversal of Previous Policies: The order also seeks to undo or amend policies from the previous administration that acknowledged gender identity protections, such as the 2020 Bostock v. Clayton County decision, which expanded workplace protections to include sexual orientation and gender identity.
Harmful Aspects and Misinformation:
Misrepresentation of Gender Identity: The executive order frames gender identity as "subjective" and "fluid," implying that it is disconnected from biology and therefore invalid. This misrepresents the experiences of transgender people, who typically have a deep and consistent understanding of their gender identity, which does not align with their assigned sex at birth. Denying this reality perpetuates stigma and discrimination against transgender people, particularly transgender women who would be excluded from spaces meant for women.
Denial of Scientific Understanding: Modern science recognizes that sex and gender are more complex than a simple binary. While biological sex (e.g., chromosomes, reproductive organs) is typically categorized as male or female, gender is increasingly understood as a spectrum that encompasses a range of identities beyond this binary. The order misrepresents the scientific consensus on this matter, which acknowledges that gender identity is an important aspect of human identity and that it can be fluid or not always align with assigned sex at birth.
Harm to Transgender and Gender Non-Conforming Individuals: The order is harmful to transgender and gender non-conforming individuals by denying them legal recognition of their gender identity, effectively erasing their experiences. Policies that force individuals to conform to a strict male/female binary can exacerbate discrimination and harm, particularly in settings such as healthcare, prisons, and shelters, where transgender individuals may face violence or neglect if they are not properly accommodated.
Impact on Women’s Rights: The order claims to "defend women's rights" by preventing transgender women from using women’s spaces. However, this framing falsely suggests that the rights of cisgender women are inherently in conflict with the rights of transgender women. In reality, protecting transgender rights, including access to single-sex spaces consistent with their gender identity, does not diminish the rights or safety of cisgender women. The order's focus on this false dichotomy undermines both women's rights and the dignity of transgender people.
Undermining Legal Protections: By reversing or restricting legal recognition of gender identity in federal policies, the order undermines critical protections for LGBTQ+ people. For example, the reversal of the Bostock ruling, which expanded civil rights protections under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, threatens the legal recognition of transgender people in the workplace. This could lead to increased discrimination and legal challenges to rights that have already been secured through court rulings.
Increased Social Division: The framing of the order as a battle between "biological reality" and "gender ideology" fosters division and antagonism toward LGBTQ+ people, particularly transgender people. Rather than promoting understanding, this order contributes to a culture of discrimination and misinformation, leading to a less inclusive and more polarized society.
Conclusion:
The January 20, 2025 Executive Order is harmful because it relies on a narrow, outdated, and scientifically inaccurate understanding of sex and gender. It spreads misinformation about transgender identities, reduces the dignity and rights of transgender people, and undermines legal protections based on gender identity. While it claims to protect women’s rights, it does so in a way that divides rather than unites, fostering an environment of discrimination and exclusion.
If you, or someone you love, is in crisis, please take the time to save and share the numbers below.
National Suicide Prevention Lifeline
Call: 988
Available 24/7
LGBT National Coming Out Support Hotline
888-OUT-LGBT (888-688-5428)
LGBT National Help Center
Youth Talkline: 800-246-7743
Senior Hotline: 888-234-7243
Monday thru Friday, 4pm to midnight ET; Saturday from noon to 5pm ET
SAGE LGBT Elder Hotline
1-877-360-LGBT (5428)
Connects LGBT elders and caretakers with friendly responders who are ready to listen. Available 24/7, in English and Spanish, with translation in 180 languages.
Trans Lifeline
Trans Lifeline’s Hotline is a confidential 24/7 peer support phone service run by trans people for trans and questioning people. Call us if you need someone trans to talk to, even if you’re not in crisis or if you’re not sure you’re trans.
1-877-565-8860 (United States)
1-877-330-6366 (Canada)
Oprime 2 para hablar con unx operadxr en español.
Trevor Project
Phone: 1-866-488-7386
Text START to 678-678
